A practical, do-no-harm guide to help you freshen up trophies and plaques at home without scratching, stripping plating or lifting lacquer.
A quick bit of detective work will save you headaches later. Many trophies are a mix - think a metal cup on a wooden plinth with felt underneath - so treat each part on its own terms and keep liquids away from joints, screws and the base. Start with the metal:
If your cup has hallmarks (for example, the lion passant for sterling), you’re likely looking at solid silver; no hallmarks and a slightly different tone at worn edges usually means silver-plate. Unlike solid silver trophies, plated pieces have only a thin layer of silver over a base metal, so the safest approach is light washing and a gentle silver cloth rather than anything abrasive.
For brass, decide whether it’s lacquered or unlacquered. Lacquered brass has a glassy, even shine that doesn’t tarnish in patches; polishing it like bare metal will just scratch the clear coat. Unlacquered brass does darken naturally over time and can take a non-abrasive brass polish sparingly, after a mild soapy wash.
Gold-plated cups are typically brass beneath a very thin gold layer. Treat them as delicate plating: mild soap, soft cloth, no scouring powders, no “home remedies” that rely on acids or abrasives.
Awards made from acrylic/plastic behave differently to glass or crystal. Acrylic is lighter and warmer to the touch and scratches easily - avoid ammonia, acetone and alcohol. Glass and crystal can handle a little more, but you still want mild cleaners and to apply them to the cloth rather than spraying near wooden bases.
Finally, look at wooden plaques and plinths. A sealed or varnished finish will tolerate a lightly damp cloth; unfinished wood should be kept dry and dusted only. Whatever you’re cleaning, support it on a soft towel so you’re not chasing dings while you chase fingerprints.
Silver and silver-plate respond best to the gentlest possible treatment. Plated items have only a thin layer of silver over a base metal, so the aim is to clean, not scour.
Why chemical dips are risky: dips can creep into hollow components and are hard to rinse out fully; they may pit or etch the surface and will remove a little silver each time, thinning silver-plate. If you’re unsure whether a piece is plated or hollow, avoid dips entirely.
Good to know: abrasive pastes and wadding remove metal along with tarnish - use sparingly, if at all. Store silver away from sulphur sources and prioritise dusting over frequent polishing. If in doubt, stop and ask a professional.
First decide if the brass is lacquered (sealed) or unlacquered (bare). The care is different and treating lacquered brass like bare metal will scratch the clear coat.
Lacquered brass - step-by-step
Unlacquered brass - step-by-step
Tips and cautions: home mixes such as lemon or vinegar can etch bare brass and stain adjacent materials - use with care and rinse thoroughly, or avoid. Always test any product on an inconspicuous area first; if unsure whether it’s lacquered, treat it as sealed and stick to a damp-wipe only.
Gold-plated cups are usually brass beneath an ultra-thin gold layer. The rule is simple: be gentle and avoid anything abrasive or chemically aggressive.
Avoid: abrasive polishes, powders, metal wadding, scouring pads and “tarnish removers”; acidic or alkaline home remedies can undercut or strip the plating.
Good to know: if marks persist, it may be the base metal showing through - further polishing will only make it worse. Consider re-plating rather than continued cleaning.
Acrylic (PMMA) scratches and “crazes” easily. Keep the method simple and solvent-free, and handle with clean microfibre at all times.
Avoid: ammonia, acetone, alcohol and glass cleaners that contain them (they cause clouding and stress-cracks), plus abrasive pads, paper towels or gritty cloths. Only use products specifically labelled acrylic-safe if absolutely necessary.
Handling and storage: keep a dedicated clean microfibre for acrylic, store in a dust-free cabinet, and avoid stacking pieces directly against each other. If in doubt, stop - DIY polishing can easily make deep scratches worse.
Wood needs a lighter touch than metal. Start by identifying the finish: sealed/varnished wood will tolerate a barely damp wipe, while waxed or oiled surfaces prefer dry cleaning and a light re-wax. Unfinished wood should not be wet-cleaned at all. Whatever the finish, keep moisture to a minimum, apply any cleaner to the cloth (not directly to the plaque), and steer clear of joints, felt, screws and nameplates.
Avoid: soaking or steaming, spraying polish directly onto the wood, abrasive pads, and solvent-heavy or silicone furniture sprays that leave residues and can interfere with future refinishing. Never flood edges, veneers, or end grain—swelling and lifting are hard to reverse.
Good to know: if you spot lifted veneer, loose screws, deep water rings or cracks, pause and seek advice. Keep wooden bases away from radiators and direct sunlight, add soft pads underneath to protect shelves, and give pieces a little space so they don’t rub against neighbouring awards.
Some pieces are better left to a professional clean. If a silver or silver-plated trophy has heavy, uneven tarnish that doesn’t shift with mild soap and a silver cloth, repeated polishing can thin the surface and soften engraving. Stop if you notice reddish or yellow tones breaking through on “silver” areas (that’s the base metal showing), any lifting or crazing of lacquer on brass, or pitting on gold-plate. Mixed-material cups with hollow stems or handles are also risky to treat at home because liquids can wick into joints, felt, or wood.
Other red flags include loose finials or handles, missing screws, enamel badges, inlaid stones, or a wooden base with lifted veneer. If any of these apply, it’s time to escalate: we can advise on safe cleaning, re-securing hardware, replacing damaged plates, or referring for professional re-plating where appropriate.
Prevention beats polishing. Handle trophies with clean cotton or nitrile gloves and give them a gentle dust with a soft microfibre cloth before fingerprints harden. Keep displays away from kitchens, bathrooms, radiators, and direct sunlight; stable conditions help - think moderate humidity and temperature, not the window ledge in full sun.
For silver, store in a closed cabinet with anti-tarnish cloths or strips and keep sulphur sources (rubber bands, some papers and foams) well away. Dusting plus the very occasional pass with a quality silver cloth is kinder than frequent polishing. Brass fares best when you know the finish: lacquered brass only needs light damp-wiping and drying; unlacquered brass can take a sparing, non-abrasive polish after washing. Acrylic awards should be cleaned with mild soapy water and their own dedicated microfibre - no ammonia, acetone, or alcohol. Glass and crystal like a final wipe with distilled water to avoid spots; always apply cleaner to the cloth, not directly over wooden plinths.
For wood bases and plaques, stick to dry dusting or a barely damp cloth on sealed finishes, and avoid silicone sprays that leave residues. Store pieces with a little air around them so they don’t rub together, and use soft pads under bases to prevent scratches on shelves.
Sometimes the smartest move isn’t more elbow grease - it’s a refresh. If the nameplate is scratched or past its best, we can replace it with a new engraved plate (brass, aluminium, or brass-look laminate) matched to size and fixings. Perpetual trophies can be revived with fresh year bars or side shields, and we can add missing winners to keep the record complete. Worn ribbons, tired centres or plinth bands can be swapped for new ones to lift the whole presentation without touching the original cup.
If a finish is failing - gold-plate thinning, silver-plate worn through, or lacquer badly damaged - you may need to consider further actions; from gentle conservation cleaning to re-engraving or referral for professional re-plating. The result is a trophy that looks loved and ready for its next presentation, without risking the details that make it special.
!